Skip to Content
Your web browser is out of date. Update your browser for more security, speed and the best experience on this site.
Scott Marsteller Varied

Scott Marsteller MD

Family Medicine, General
4.7 out of 5
View Reviews

Main Street Family Medicine

617 Main Street Brookville, IN 47012


Monday: 8am - 7pm Tuesday: 8am - 7pm Wednesday: 8am - 5pm Thursday: 8am - 5pm Friday: 8am-5pm

Training & Education

Institution (City/State)
University of California San Diego
Bryn Mawr Hospital (Pennsylvania)
Bryn Mawr Hospital (Pennsylvania)
Medical School
Temple University School Of Medicine
Medical School
Temple University School of Medicine (Pennsylvania)

Review Distribution


Reviews Breakdown

Provider Explained Things Clearly
Provider Rating
Were you seen by this provider in a timely manner?
Did the care providers listen carefully to you?
Did this care provider seem to know your medical history?
Did you trust this provider with your care?
Did this provider talk about how to prevent illness or injury?

Scott Marsteller Reviews

4.7 262
May 22, 2024

The doctor and everyone in his employ are knowledgeable and very nice.

May 21, 2024

Dr Scott Marsteller was absolutely fantastic! I have referred my sister and friends to him . He took his time to listen to my issues and asks excellent questions to help guide us to the right care. Extremely knowledgeable physician. Excellent bed side manor and provided excellent advice and care . Reid is very fortunate to have him.

May 16, 2024

He is very thorough and lightens the mood. He's very easy to talk with.

May 16, 2024


May 14, 2024

Very professional.

May 14, 2024

Dr. Marsteller is a very conscientious doctor. I like that he keeps track of my wellness tests. He also approves of my supplements.

May 14, 2024


Apr 30, 2024

Always happy with my treatment at his office.

Apr 30, 2024

Very nice staff, very efficient. Thank you

Apr 25, 2024

Really good experience this morning for my first time at Dr. Marsteller's Connersville location. Violet, Jessica, and Dr. Marsteller are a great team!!!

Apr 16, 2024

Good job

Apr 10, 2024

Scott Marsteller is an awesome doctor

Apr 10, 2024

Dr. Scott Marsteller is a competent physician who develops a good relationship with his patients. He handles the health issues quickly, professionally, and ensures the patient has all the information necessary and all their questions answered.

Mar 27, 2024

They listened. Like really listened.

Mar 19, 2024

I trust my pervider and Reid with my health. Thank you (all)

Mar 18, 2024

1st time at this office, have been seeing the Doctor many times before in Brookville. Going to the present office is much better, it is less than 5 minutes from my home. Will be continuing to see him at this office.

Mar 14, 2024

Great care

Mar 14, 2024

Good Doctor and Staff

Mar 11, 2024

I'm part of the Anthem blue cross blue shield group that will lose coverage soon. Greed sucks, guess I'll have to find a new doctor. Maybe go Kettering

Mar 7, 2024

I really like my Dr and I wouldn't want anyone else taking care of me

Mar 7, 2024

Scott Marsteller isn't a good Dr. He doesn't listen to anything you try and tell him and I wouldn't recommend him to fix a sick dog. At least not anymore he started out great and now it's like he doesn't care whether people live or die.

Mar 7, 2024

Dr. Marsteller is an amazing doctor. His staff are very friendly.

Feb 29, 2024

Very friendly, efficient, patient and understanding

Feb 19, 2024

Very professional Listened to my concerns Gave me answers

Feb 19, 2024

Very good

Feb 15, 2024

I disagree with my care. Was told to stay on medicine that causes me pain and nausea.

Feb 13, 2024

Pleasant to talk enjoyed the session.

Feb 12, 2024

Hate that Dr Marstellar is leaving Brookville but glad that a new provider is already in place.

Feb 8, 2024

Great staff at Dr.Marsteller

Feb 8, 2024

I have some history from my son's Dr as a child through age 22 that I need to have sent to this doctor.. I plan to work on that before the next visit.

Feb 7, 2024

He shows a caring heart to the needs of his patients.He does a great job at going over everything.

Feb 7, 2024

This was my first office visit today. Everyone was very friendly and helpful. I felt very comfortable and will definitely be back.

Feb 6, 2024

Dr. Marsteller and his staff are fantastic. We have the greatest of confidence Dr. Marsteller and are fortunate to have him as our physician.

Feb 2, 2024

All good but I haven't gotten the last two appointment reminders. The receptionist was trying to fix the issue.

Jan 30, 2024

I was treated very well by all staff and my doctor. I always feel comfortable, knowing that my questions will be answered during my visit.

Jan 11, 2024

Dr. Marsteller and his staff are so thorough and professional, but beyond that, they actually listen and talk to you, and show real compassion.

Jan 9, 2024

I would highly recommend Dr Marsteller. He was on time, took his time and listened to all of my questions and then made suggestions to improve my health.

Jan 8, 2024

Dr Marsteller is the best doctor I've had. Now he is leaving to go back to his other practice. He will be missed by many

Jan 8, 2024

They are always very attentive and seem concerned about me at this office.

Jan 5, 2024

I absolutely felt listened to and confidence that if I have something going on that the provider will most definitely get to the bottom of it.

Jan 5, 2024

Very rushed, seems the provider didn't have time to talk about my concerns

Jan 5, 2024

Dr Marstellar was very compassionate and knowledgeable about my condition. He spent a lot of time discussing my options. I trust him.

Jan 4, 2024

Dr. Marsteller is very through and really understanding and listen to what concerns I have.. Would definitely recommend him to family..

Jan 4, 2024

Very nice people

Jan 3, 2024

Dr. M is my primary doctor. I feel that he knows about me and is willing to take time to answer my questions, even on a super busy day.

Jan 2, 2024

Dr Marsteller, Violet and his staff were caring, and courteous and address all my concerns.

Dec 21, 2023

Always have a good experience when I have to see Dr. Marsteller.

Dec 19, 2023

Dr. Marsteller is a fantastic provider.

Dec 19, 2023

Dr. Marstellar is a wonderful and compassionate Dr. I can't say the same for my cardiologist Dr Jeffery Haist.

Dec 18, 2023

Everyone was polite and prompt I have no complaints.

Dec 18, 2023

Dr. Marsteller and the nurse were very attentive to my health and offered superior care.

Dec 6, 2023

Brandi was great!

Dec 6, 2023

I felt very comfortable today I had to get an injection in my knee The nurse and Dr. Marsteller both made me feel at ease

Nov 30, 2023

Very friendly staff!! Feel very comfortable and at home in this office. He takes the time to talk to me in detail and doesn't seem hurried.

Nov 29, 2023

Everyone was very kind and efficient

Nov 29, 2023

Dr marstellar is so kind and smart and all the staff is awesome

Nov 29, 2023

Very professional and nice people

Nov 16, 2023

Very professional and informative about my health issues.

Nov 9, 2023

People just need more time to talk to there doctors. All doctors don't take enough time to talk with their patients. We have things to talk to our doctors about, and we have questions , but all doctors don't have, or take the time to discuss these questions, and worries. For the prices doctors charge nowadays, they should give us the time for these concerns.

Nov 7, 2023

Dont change anything

Nov 2, 2023

They genuinely seemed to care about the things I was concerned with

Nov 1, 2023

Got in and out in very timely period. Very thankful after working nightshift

Oct 25, 2023

-- My name is xxx-- At 60 old, Dr. Marsteller is only my 2nd primary D

Oct 23, 2023

It was my first visit and I felt listened to. I felt my opinion and things I said had value to them.

Oct 17, 2023

Nice job

Oct 11, 2023

Great Experience.

Oct 9, 2023

I enjoy going to see Dr Marsteller. I feel that he really cares and listens to me. I am comfortable with him and he is down to earth

Oct 5, 2023

Always receive excellent care

Oct 5, 2023

Doctor is very curtious

Oct 4, 2023

They even helped me get out of the car and back in the car after the visit

Sep 28, 2023

Dr. Scott Marstellar and his staff are amazing! It is a real pleasure to go to the doctor. Dr. Marstellar is very knowledgeable and listens and has such an awesome attitude in dealing with my problems. A great doctor!

Sep 21, 2023

Dr Marsteller, is a great and professional Dr.He takes time to listen to your concerns.. He will find the best treatment for you.. He sent me to the right place,went there was a problem with my kidneys that showed up. I was diagnosed with kidney cancer..He very well could have saved my life...I am now scheduled for kidney surgery to remove the mass.

Sep 21, 2023

This was the best experience I have ever had at a Reid office. I was promptly greeted by a smiling face! Vi is always such a great face to see first, always has a smile and would put any patient at ease with her kind demeanor. I was taken back for my appointment well before I was even scheduled. The employee who took me to my room was wonderful and polite. Dr. Marsteller is always great. Thorough but quick. Great patient care from all members I encountered today at my well check. Job well done!

Sep 20, 2023

That the staff and nurses and Dr were amazing,helpful and understanding,I hadn't been since they relocated,lol went to my appointment at old address .called from there to find out where to go?? and they we're extremely nice about it and understanding I was running late ? there awesome in Brookville.

Sep 18, 2023

Dr. Marsteller is a kind, concerned, thorough person.

Sep 14, 2023

Gave a good examination for a first visit. I felt like he listened extremely well. Was very nice and made me feel comfortable.

Sep 14, 2023

This was a phone interview before my visit with physician pre wellness visit.

Sep 13, 2023

Very satisfied with my doctor and the nurses would recommend anyone to go there

Sep 6, 2023

I spent 30 to 45 minutes in the room waiting to be released. Thought I had been forgotten.

Sep 5, 2023

The Dr was friendly, kind and knowledgable

Aug 30, 2023

This was the first time I met my daughters doctor, and he was very professional and very nice.

Aug 30, 2023

The staff Nancy and Jessica were wonderful and very professional. Dr. Marsteller is a great doctor and very knowledgeable and caring.

Aug 30, 2023

Very well mannered establishment

Aug 24, 2023

Dr marsteller is a wonderful Doctor and has helped with my health issues for years. Love his knowledge and his staff is very sweet kind informative. Couldn't ask for a better Doctor Thank you xxx

Aug 24, 2023

Great visit

Aug 24, 2023

I think Dr. Marsteller is a great Dr and cares for his patients. His staff is amazing!

Aug 23, 2023

Everything went well. Already have tests results.

Aug 21, 2023

He did not know my history because I had never seen him before.

Aug 16, 2023

Dr Scott and his staff were professional courteous, knowledgeable, helpful, and armed with a great bedside manner! Brookville is blessed to have such a great doctor!

Aug 16, 2023

The staff was very timely and friendly. Dr Marsteller always talks in a way that is easily understood. He answers any questions I have and explains everything well.

Aug 16, 2023

The office and medical staff were so kind and gracious.

Aug 10, 2023

Dr Marsteller was very attentive to me. I appreciate that. I was impressed with him as MY DOCTOR.

Aug 9, 2023

Pleased with the manner in which the provider handled my situation.

Aug 9, 2023

Love the new facility; the staff and my doctor have always been wonderful.

Aug 2, 2023


Jul 24, 2023

Excellent doctor and nurses!

Jul 13, 2023

I am well pleased with this Doctor

Jul 13, 2023

Everyone in the office and the doctor made me feel at ease and answered all of my questions. The doctor talked with me and gave me suggestions for several issues. I'm glad to find a doctor who cares about his patients!!

Jul 12, 2023

Great people at Reid. Always friendly and helpful

Jul 11, 2023

Dr. Marsteller has given me great advice about my health over the last 6 months. I had extremely high blood pressure and I was slightly overweight. After talking to him I started walking every day and counting my sodium and sugar intake. I've lost 45 pounds in 6 months, my blood pressure has gone way down and I feel better than I have in years.

Jul 11, 2023

The doctor and nurses made you feel vary comfortable.

Jul 6, 2023

Good experience

Jul 5, 2023

Dr Marsteller and his staff is awesome!!

Jul 5, 2023

Great dr great staff

Jun 29, 2023

Wonderful! Informative, trustworthy. I am very thankful to have him as my physician.

Jun 27, 2023

I love Doctor Scott I call him and everyone is so friendly and the office is really clean and pretty I love the Christian sayings .

Jun 27, 2023

I am new too this doctor so we are establishing my care.but they are friendly and good people so fare