Skip to Content
Your web browser is out of date. Update your browser for more security, speed and the best experience on this site.
James Nuttall Varied

James Nuttall MD

Surgery- Orthopedic- General
4.5 out of 5
View Reviews


First Appointment

Why Orthopedics?

Reid Health Comprehensive Bone & Joint Center

1400 Highland Road Suite 1 Richmond, IN 47374


Monday: 8am - 5pm Tuesday: 8am - 5pm Wednesday: 8am - 5pm Thursday: 8am - 5pm Friday: 8am - 4pm

Practice Information

Reid Health Comprehensive Bone & Joint
1400 Highland Road Ste 1 Richmond IN, 47374-8810
(765) 935-8905
(765) 939-4200
1475 E State Road 44 Ste 3 Connersville IN, 47331-0219
(765) 825-8686
(765) 827-8525

Training & Education

Institution (City/State)
Rutgers University
08/01/2016 - 07/01/2017
Medical School
Royal College of Physicians of Ireland
09/01/2007 - 06/30/2011
McMaster University School of Medicine
07/01/2011 - 06/30/2016

Board Data

Board Certified
Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada

Review Distribution


Reviews Breakdown

Provider Explained Things Clearly
Provider Rating
Were you seen by this provider in a timely manner?
Did the care providers listen carefully to you?
Did this care provider seem to know your medical history?
Did you trust this provider with your care?
Did this provider talk about how to prevent illness or injury?

James Nuttall Reviews

4.5 177
Mar 20, 2023

Very professional and everything is completed in a timely manner. They all call you by your first name like they have known you forever.Recommend this hospital to all!

Mar 17, 2023

Amazing! Very friendly staff! And very compassionate

Mar 17, 2023

Please with the provider and his team

Mar 17, 2023

I trust having Dr. Nuttall my son had him and he saved his leg.

Feb 28, 2023

Dr. Nuttall is an excellent doctor, very caring and great provider

Feb 23, 2023

Very, nice, very understanding about how you have concerns , he's caring about your problems, and health,

Feb 21, 2023

Good experience very accommodating overall I had an excellent experience.

Feb 17, 2023


Feb 16, 2023

He has became our family orthopedic doctor because of his care to our family members

Feb 14, 2023

Always pleased with my appointment with Dr. Nuttall and staff

Feb 13, 2023

My waning time in the room was a little over 1 hour

Jan 26, 2023

Was happy with the service I did refer a friend to this doctor.

Jan 24, 2023

Everyone was so kind.

Jan 17, 2023

Dr Nuttall is P 0t wasn't for him I would not be walking. Thank you Dr Nutall and Team!!!

Jan 13, 2023

He is the best surgeon anyone could ask for. Always friendly and easy to talk to. Love him.

Dec 22, 2022

Dr. Nuttall talked to me about options for the cortisone shot to knee replacement.

Dec 20, 2022

I got more answers coming out of state to this provider than I did going to the ones in Ohio

Dec 20, 2022

I have been very satisfied with my experience.

Dec 8, 2022

He was so nice explained every treatment option to me !

Dec 2, 2022

I felt very safe today with the staff

Dec 2, 2022

It was helpful.

Nov 11, 2022

Very pleased with my visit! Staff were professional and friendly. Dr Nuttall was very thorough and I completely trust him with my care. Well done Ortho!

Nov 8, 2022

He's very good .

Oct 28, 2022

Had a question after the dr left the room and caught him in the hallway, and he was more than happy to answer the other questions I had and give further advice!!??

Oct 21, 2022

The provider and staff had good bedside manner. They put my mind at ease about my joint issue.

Oct 21, 2022

Covered all our questions in detail Very informative

Oct 21, 2022

I love Dr Nuttall he is the best but last time I did your survey I had a very rude gentleman contact me and upset me so I love my doctor but please don't have anyone call me that's going to be little me thank you0

Oct 20, 2022

I appreciated that someone seemed to be interested in my issue and finding a solution.

Oct 7, 2022

Even though I saw Dr what seemed like an hour after appt time, he listen to what I had to say and he talked to me about my injury.

Oct 7, 2022

Always love coming to see my doctor they make feel there family

Oct 6, 2022

Everybody at Ortho was amazing!!! The rooming process was thorough and made sure they talked to my son to get accurate information while still Taking his parents concerns into consideration! Dr Nuttall was very thorough and a great physician! I do have some concerns with phone scheduling. I originally scheduled a follow up with Nuttall after my sons original visit while in office. Check out process was great! MRI scheduling was efficient and easy to work with!!! My sons MRI was scheduled 2 day after his first appt!!! Awesome!!! I called in to see if could move up my sons appt, was told there was nothing sooner. Understandable and not a big deal. I work within the Reid system so I know how difficult new patient follow ups can be yo get scheduled! I remembered that ortho had outreach offices so I called back later in the day and got the same lady. Again asked to move the appt up and told her we were ok traveling yo another office to get results sooner if anything was available. The lady answering the phone was rude and seemed as if I was bothering her to call and ask for a sooner appt. When I told her I work within Reid and knew that ortho went to satellite offices she quickly changed her demeanor and pleasantly gave me a follow up appt in Connersville 7 days sooner! Please consider offering all options when a patient calls in!! Some are willing to make the drive to get the answers and start the plan of care to get treatment started!!!

Oct 3, 2022

Everyone was very nice and friendly.

Oct 3, 2022

Dr Nuttall was friendly and answered all my questions.

Sep 27, 2022

He waited for me to conference in my son. Asked if he had any questions in addition to me. Very thorough in options and explanations.

Sep 27, 2022

The Orthopedic team did a great job explaining the process to us.

Sep 23, 2022

Very happy with appointment

Sep 23, 2022

Everyone in this practice has had the utmost caring ability to provide the best care I have ever received

Sep 16, 2022

Very pleased with provider

Sep 13, 2022

Dr Nuttall was very insightful. Have recommendations follow up in 3 months

Sep 13, 2022

Polite staff and doctor

Sep 1, 2022

Dr. Nuttall and his staff were extremely efficient. They did exactly what the doctor requested and xrays and all went very smoothly. Appreciated all of them and he is one of the kindest doctors I have went to. Thanks to all there in Connersville Specialty Clinic.

Sep 1, 2022

Waited 45 mins past scheduled appointment before being seen.

Aug 26, 2022

First time to see Dr. Nuttall. Impressed. Would recommend. Given knowledgeable info to me.

Aug 16, 2022

All the staff was courteous,professional and friendly.

Aug 4, 2022

Everyone was very kind and considerate and very helpful and professional. Thank you Reid Health.

Aug 2, 2022

They are all very nice and great at there job I will be coming for several visits I even will be coming for some health issues that I was supposed to go to Dayton for

Aug 2, 2022

Dr. Nuttall is very kind and a good doctor.

Aug 2, 2022

Exceeded my expectations, comparable to medical treatment I received during the past 22 years in Florida where the medical system is geared to senior care

Jul 25, 2022

Everyone is wonderful and very helpful

Jul 21, 2022

He seemed very knowledgeable about his field!! Put me at ease. He showed me my x-rays and explained what the problem was. He was very nice.

Jul 21, 2022

He seemed to act like the disease I have had for 30 years was nothing and not painful when I have been in constant pain. Was just very upset by how I felt like an idiot

Jul 19, 2022

My doctor office did not provide my MRI I am sorry for that !

Jul 19, 2022

always a comprehensive and complete appt Waited much to long to be seen

Jul 12, 2022

I was very pleased with the care I received a big thank you

Jul 11, 2022

All staff members: Reception, nursing, physician, and checkout were welcoming, friendly, courteous, and professional. I felt that everyone I observed truly enjoyed working at Reid Healthcare and Orthopedics.

Jul 5, 2022

The worse experience I have ever had with a dr

Jul 5, 2022

Wonderful nice people

Jun 17, 2022

I am really happy with my visit with Dr. Nuttall. I feel extremely comfortable putting my care in his hands.

Jun 16, 2022

The health care providers to my life style and what I expected my outcome to be and saw to it that I was getting the best treatments for my situation. I am completely satisfied.

Jun 16, 2022

Dr. Nuttall, and his staff, very kind and professional.

May 26, 2022

Everyone was very nice and kind

May 24, 2022

Dr. Nuttall is one of the better dr.s that I have seen in years. There needs to be more like him

May 24, 2022

My doc is wonderful

May 24, 2022

Yes perfect

May 23, 2022

very helpful with questions. confident with himself and his experience.

May 16, 2022

Dr Nuttall was very professional It was my first visit. He and his CMA made sure I had everything I needed. Very kind

May 12, 2022

I always feel iam in good hands with any of my appointments

May 5, 2022

Really feel comfortable with Doctor Nuttall and his team

Apr 26, 2022

Like the doctor very well.

Apr 25, 2022

Doctor Nuttall very good really like he sits and talks answer all question highly recomend him

Apr 21, 2022

Dr Nuttall is a great. He gave me options for my shoulder and even had me come into see another orthopedic surgeon so that I had all my options for my care. And the fact that he personally called me and suggested that for my piece of mind for me to see a second dr. really made me feel that he listened to me and my concerns.